Recycle and Reuse

One of the themes of my recent sabbatical was “Recycle and Reuse.” This is logical given how much of my trip was focused on history and archaeology, but it was noteworthy nonetheless. It was not just that so many of these churches and sites had been in use for 2000-plus years; it was how many times they had been torn down, burned down, or destroyed, only to be rebuilt. When I visited the Cathedral of Florence (Duomo di Firenze), the church was in the middle of a major restoration. Many areas of the building's exterior were brilliantly clean, while other areas still showed signs of industrial pollution. The Duomo looked old and new at the same time. Underneath St. Peter’s Cathedral of Geneva is an archaeological site that traces worship at that location to a time before Jesus. It is believed that Genevans venerated a local chieftain on that site before a Catholic church was built there. Layer after layer of dirt and debris speaks to the many periods of worship there. One church burned down and was replaced. Another church structure was continually added to for centuries until it was torn down to make way for a larger church. Famously, the Protestant Reformers “reused” the cathedral and made it their own, stripping the former Roman Catholic building of its decorations.
We often resist this sort of recycling and reusing in the American church. The timelines are much shorter, but our love of the (recent) past makes it challenging for churches to recycle, renew, or even reinvent themselves. I recently spoke to a pastor who lamented the conversations that would come up on Sunday because new carpet had been installed that week! Several years ago, a dying local congregation was approached by a fast-growing new church development about renting space for worship. The church had more space than they could possibly use or afford, and the new church development needed a larger sanctuary for Sunday worship. On paper, the proposal made sense. The new church development would gradually take ownership of the building, while the current church membership would have space to worship for the foreseeable future. The church’s leadership rejected the proposal because they did not want to be replaced. A few years later, the church closed, and the building was sold to another congregation.
As Presbyterians, we frequently claim our identity as heirs to the Reformation. We are “the reformed and always reforming,” but how much do we actually do that? Do we reform and change? Do we recycle and reuse? Are we open to the new things that the Holy Spirit is doing in our midst? The history of the church, especially the archaeological history, is full of evidence of reinvention and renewal. Where do you see that in your church?
Blessings,
Rev. Tim Blodgett
General Presbyter
Eastern Oklahoma Presbytery





Comments